VERDICT A period of transition as Adobe gets to grips with its Macromedia inheritance and the changing nature of the web.

Adobe’s background is in print design and its web efforts such as GoLive and ImageReady were less than impressive. It seemed something of a miracle then when Macromedia agreed to be taken over, allowing Adobe to add the market-leading web apps to its market-leading print portfolio.

VERDICT Plenty of design-rich development power for producing desktop EXEs - but the new browser-hosted Silverlight applications promise more than they currently deliver.
Everyone’s computing experience depends on the richness of the applications that they use both on the desktop and on the web. However there’s always been a factor holding that richness in check: a fundamental and frustrating chasm between the designer working on application presentation and the developer working on application logic. Just over a year ago Microsoft unveiled its ground-up solution to the problem and now, with Expression Studio 2, it is building on those foundations.

VERDICT Minor tweaks leave Expression Media looking even more old-fashioned, under-powered and out of its depth.
Microsoft Expression Studio is designed to provide end users with the richest computing experience possible so advanced media handling should be key. Unfortunately this obvious requirement seemed to pass Microsoft by so that, rather than developing its own visual file manager, it was forced to buy in an existing third-party solution at the last moment. Worse the program it picked, iView MediaPro, was ugly, awkward and well past its sell-by date.

VERDICT Top-of-the-range video preparation and encoding together with Silverlight-based web playback should give Encoder a winning edge – but doesn’t quite.
There’s one media format that can make or break the computing experience – video. That’s why it’s so important to get the right balance between quality and file size and why both Adobe and Microsoft provide dedicated video encoders. Surprisingly, despite Adobe’s longstanding video experience, this is one area where Microsoft outscores its rival.

VERDICT New interface and animation features and the ability to produce simple cross-platform Silverlight browser applications – too simple.
Expression Blend lies at the heart of Microsoft’s mission to make application development richer and more efficient as this is where you design the end user interface. XAML, Microsoft’s presentational markup language, is naturally central and Blend is the one Studio application where you can directly edit your XAML complete with full coding support. To code efficiently you really need to be able to see the effect of your changes as you work and Blend 2 adds the crucial Split view that makes this possible.

VERDICT Flex steps up a gear with improved CS3 integration and data connection and new desktop capabilities.
Flash began life as a way for web designers to add simple vector animations to their web pages. In the twelve years since it has grafted on impressive content handling, interactivity and programmability and become the one must-have browser plug-in. In the process, and almost unnoticed, Flash has turned itself into an online computing platform with Flash content viewable by almost all internet users. Now Adobe is determined to fully capitalize on this platform by unleashing Flash’s ability to create full-blown, self-contained Rich Internet Applications (RIAs) – and to take the same power to the desktop (see AIR boxout).

RECOMMENDED

VERDICT: Improved recording capabilities, richer design and interactivity and deeper integration with PowerPoint see Captivate build on existing strengths.

Adobe Captivate is a Flash-based solution for computer-based training (CBT). The use of Flash provides an immediate and massive advantage as it means that Captivate’s output is automatically viewable by anyone with the Flash player installed – roughly 98% of users with an internet connection...

Tom Arah gets to grips with Microsoft’s new Expression Studio and Silverlight platforms and wonders how they will fare against Adobe’s Flash.

Recently I looked at how Adobe is reworking Flash in preparation for the coming battle with Microsoft over the Rich Internet Application (RIA) space and, with it, the likely future of computer-based design...

VERDICT: Radical improvement of the production workflow for desktop application development - and of the results that can be achieved.

Expression Blend is the central component of the new Expression Studio suite and of Microsoft’s drive to become a major player in the world of design software...

VERDICT: Disappointingly cut-down graphics application designed to work hand-in-hand with Expression Blend.

When Microsoft bought the innovative graphics application, Creature House Expression, there was brave talk of taking on Adobe Illustrator in terms of vector handling, Photoshop in terms of bitmaps and Fireworks in terms of web graphics...