InDesign CS3 review

Filed under:

InDesign CS3 again raises the bar for publishing

RECOMMENDED

VERDICT: New effects enable richer design results while a host of other improvements boost productivity.

By combining photos from Photoshop and illustrations from Illustrator with its own text, layout, formatting and output strengths, InDesign CS3 stands out as the central application in Adobe’s vision of the modern publishing workflow. It also stands out because it is the only one of the three main CS3 design applications that faces any serious competition.
In particular, to win the coveted high-end publishing crown from QuarkXPress, InDesign has to tackle head-on the one area in which Quark has always excelled – productivity. The working environment is crucial here and the latest InDesign benefits from the new CS3 shared interface based on customisable workspaces built on floatable palettes stacked neatly in collapsible docker windows to either side of the screen. For the other CS3 applications this revolutionizes working life but, as InDesign CS2 already boasted a similar system, here the benefits are less radical.
However there are plenty of other enhancements that do boost productivity enormously: more control is now available via the main context-sensitive Control bar; the Pages palette now shows thumbnails of all pages and you can drag within it to scroll and right-click to call up context-sensitive commands; double-clicking on an image frame automatically shifts from the Select to Direct Select tool so that you can edit its content; frame fitting can now be set up in advance and as part of an object style; and the Quick Apply dialog now lists scripts as well as commands and offers filtering shortcuts.

InDesign CS3 offers numerous productivity enhancements
InDesign CS3 offers numerous productivity enhancements

The most impressive efficiency boost is completely new and will undoubtedly save hours of unnecessary effort. You can now load multiple files for placing simply by dragging and dropping from the bundled version of Bridge CS3. Each file is represented at the cursor by a preview thumbnail which you can quickly cycle through to place them in the order that you want. Multiple import naturally proves most useful when working with images but it also works with text files - and now you can also place InDesign’s own INDD files too. This new support for embedding native files is particularly significant as it means that multiple users can collaborate on a single layout. However, unlike QuarkXPress 7’s composition zones, such collaboration can’t be arranged on-the-fly and is limited to single page, rectangular areas.
As a professional publishing package, InDesign needs to be able to deal with any project that is thrown at it, and one of the main focuses of this latest release is better handling of more advanced publications. A good example is the ability to create automatically bulleted and numbered list sequences now with support for prefixes, style-based hierarchies and non-contiguous control – powerful but complex. There’s also new support for text variables which proves most valuable when linked to styles making it possible to set up running headers and footers that pick out text from the current page.
InDesign CS3 also answers the most popular feature request from users with its new support for automatic formatting of tables based on styles. As you would expect with InDesign the level of control offered is exceptional, with the ability to specify advanced features such as alternating, and custom, column and row patterns. You can also set up separate cell-based styles and these can be incorporated into the table style. The result is that you can import tables from Excel or Word and consistently format them, complete with differently-styled headers, footers and first and last column, and all with a single click.

Perhaps the single most powerful feature in the new InDesign CS3 – and positively dangerous in the wrong hands - is its radically enhanced Find/Change command. This now lets you search across multiple documents, specify whether features such as locked and hidden layers should be included, and lets you save queries for re-use. More importantly, the dialog is now tabbed so that you are no longer limited to traditional text searches, but can also search for particular glyphs or use regular expression-based GREP searches to find patterns and process the results (think wildcard searches on steroids). Most powerful of all is the new ability to find and change object properties. You can specify and change basic attributes from style, stroke and fill through to anchor position and frame fitting. You can also search and replace based on a new feature of InDesign CS3 - object effects.

New effects make it possible to produce richer designs
New effects make it possible to produce richer designs

These object effects begin with those longstanding features - transparency, blend mode, drop shadow and feathering – that helped InDesign 2 redefine print design. Now, some five years later, these have been extended again with a whole host of new effects: Inner Shadow, Outer Glow, Inner Glow, Bevel and Emboss and Satin. If these sound familiar that’s because they are exactly the same effects that Photoshop provides as layer styles. And InDesign CS3 also introduces two new options for producing Directional Feather and Gradient Feather effects, excellent for seamlessly merging an image with its background.
Thanks to its new effects, InDesign CS3 again raises the bar to enable richer-than-ever design - but perhaps just as significant is how the effects are implemented. Rather than separate palettes and multiple command dialogs, there’s now a new centralized Effects palette which offers direct control over the most important transparency and blend mode settings and drop-down access to all other effects. These are in turn all handled by a single new Effects dialog which makes it much simpler to apply multiple effects and to set up effect-based object styles. Even more powerful is the new ability to apply effects not just to the object as a whole but individually to its stroke, fill and text. In other words, even while pushing the creative design envelope, InDesign CS3 again manages to boost efficiency and control.
This overriding emphasis on productivity is taken to its natural conclusion with InDesign CS3’s improved XML handling. This now supports XSLT on import which proves both more forgiving and more flexible. More importantly, InDesign CS3 now provides a rules-processing engine that can lay out and format a page by conditionally responding to data – for example applying a particular object style to frames that contain a particular subheading style. Set up the rules and the XML correctly and you can literally sit back and watch as the publication builds itself!

-based import and export help automate design and repurposing
-based import and export help automate design and repurposing

Of course the development effort involved in such XML automation is only an option for certain types of organizations and publication, but many more users and jobs will benefit from InDesign CS3’s enhanced XML-based output. Using the new Cross Media Export commands you can now output directly to XML or to XHTML. If you link the latter to an external CSS file during export, the resulting file can be automatically formatted for browser display based on the paragraph and character styles applied. Some users will undoubtedly be sorry to see the former Package for GoLive capability disappear but, generally speaking, the greater simplicity and transparency, and the natural tie-in with the market-leading Dreamweaver, makes this a more practical route to web repurposing.
From initial import through to final output this is a comprehensive upgrade with a clear focus throughout on productivity. At times the advanced power it offers inevitably leads to complexity and those QuarkXPress fans happy within their comfort zone will accuse it of unnecessary bloat – and rightly so if they wouldn’t use the additional power. Ultimately though, the bottom line is that InDesign CS3 is capable of tackling harder jobs and producing better end results – and doing so even more efficiently than its rival.
As a standalone, and even more so as part of the Creative Suite 3 Design Standard, InDesign CS3 fully deserves its professional publishing crown.

EASE OF USE 3/6
FEATURES 6/6
VALUE FOR MONEY 5/6
OVERALL 5/6

Recommended Further Reading

Below is further reading on the subject, as recommended by amazon.com users.

Click here to find similar recommendations from amazon.co.uk



Filed under:

I was just searching for

Tom ArahTom Arah is the webmaster of designer-info.com. He has been a professional designer working with computer software since 1987. He also offers training and consultancy and since 1997 has been the contributing editor covering design issues for PC Pro, the UK's biggest-selling (and best) computer monthly.

Home | Web Design | Publishing | Bitmap (Photo) | Vector Drawing | 3D
Site Info | Site Map | Search | Contact | Guestbook |

For older content (over 300 reviews and articles) please click here

To support the site please shop via these links: Amazon.com & Amazon.co.uk